| NEW ENGLAND RAZORS | MIAMI'S FINEST | BUFFALO CURSE | FLUSHING FLASH | ||||||||
| POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year |
| QB | Drew Bledsoe | 1993 | QB | Mark Brunell | 1995 | QB | John Elway | 1983 | QB | Brett Favre | 1992 |
| QB | Drew Brees (2) | 2005 | QB | Roman Gabriel | 1962 | QB | Y.A. Tittle | 1948 | QB | Joe Ferguson | 1973 |
| QB | Terry Bradshaw | 1970 | QB | Archie Manning | 1971 | QB | Steve McNair | 1995 | QB | Ken Stabler | 1971 |
| QB | Tom Tupa* | 1989 | QB | Jake Delhomme | 2003 | HB | Franco Harris | 1972 | HB | Roger Craig | 1983 |
| HB | Edgerrin James | 1999 | QB | Marlin Briscoe | 1968 | HB | Priest Holmes | 1998 | HB | Charley Taylor | 1964 |
| HB | Jamal Anderson | 1995 | HB | Larry Johnson (2) | 2005 | HB | Neal Anderson | 1986 | HB | Jim Taylor | 1958 |
| HB | Warrick Dunn | 1997 | HB | Marcus Allen | 1982 | HB | Paul Lowe | 1960 | HB | Delvin Williams | 1974 |
| HB | Marshall Faulk | 1994 | HB | Alan Ameche | 1955 | HB | Chris Warren | 1990 | HB | Steve Van Buren | 1944 |
| WR | Eric Moulds | 1996 | HB | Matt Snell | 1964 | WR | Ernest Givins | 1986 | HB | Chet Mutryn | 1946 |
| WR | Keyshawn Johnson | 1996 | WR | Dave Middleton | 1955 | WR | Reggie Wayne | 2001 | WR | Randy Moss | 1998 |
| WR | Muhsin Muhammad | 1996 | WR | Jim Benton (1) | 1946 | WR | Plaxico Burress | 2000 | WR | Terrell Owens | 1996 |
| WR | Hines Ward | 1998 | WR | Andre Rison | 1989 | WR | Joe Horn | 1996 | WR | Rob Moore | 1990 |
| WR | Keenan McCardell | 1993 | WR | Lee Evans | 2004 | WR | Javon Walker (2) | 2004 | WR | Al Toon | 1985 |
| WR | Marques Colston | 2006 | WR | Jim Keane | 1946 | WR | Jay Novacek | 1985 | WR | Homer Jones | 1965 |
| WR | Drew Hill | 1979 | WR | Mark Carrier | 1987 | TE | Mark Bavaro | 1985 | TE | Keith Jackson | 1988 |
| TE | Ben Coates | 1991 | TE | Randy McMichael | 2002 | TE | Wesley Walls | 1989 | TE | Mickey Shuler | 1978 |
| TE | Russ Francis | 1975 | TE | Chris Cooley | 2004 | TE | Bob Schnelker (1) | 1959 | TE | Eric Green | 1990 |
| TE | Bubba Franks | 2000 | TE | Jim Whelan | 1965 | TE | Pete Mitchell | 1995 | TE | Marcus Pollard | 1996 |
| TE | Mark Chmura | 1993 | K | Nick Lowery | 1980 | K | Morten Andersen | 1983 | K | Matt Stover | 1991 |
| K | Jeff Wilkins | 1995 | P | Glenn Dobbs | 1946 | P | Sean Landeta | 1985 | P | Rohn Stark | 1982 |
| P | Chris Gardocki | 1992 | OL | Green Bay Packers | 2003 | OL | Chicago Bears | 1941 | OL | Philadelphia Eagles | 1949 |
| OL | Los Angeles Rams | 1954 | D | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 2002 | D | Pittsburgh Steelers | 1976 | D | Cleveland Browns | 1950 |
| D | Chicago Bears | 1948 | ST | Los Angeles Rams | 1984 | ST | Washington Redskins | 1978 | ST | Tennessee Titans | 2000 |
| ST | New Orleans Saints | 2002 | NOTE - NO 1 YEAR PLAYER | ||||||||
| NOTE - NO 1 YEAR PLAYER | NOTE - NO 2 YEAR PLAYER | ||||||||||
| CLEVELAND MOONDOGS | CINCINNATI BUNGHOLES | PITTSBURGH YINSERS | DALLAS TEXANS (A) | ||||||||
| POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year |
| QB | Brian Sipe | 1974 | QB | Peyton Manning | 1998 | QB | Tom Brady | 2001 | QB | Sammy Baugh - x | 1941 |
| QB | Cecil Isbell | 1941 | QB | Trent Green (2) | 2005 | QB | Michael Vick | 2001 | QB | Sid Luckman | 1941 |
| QB | Milt Plum | 1957 | QB | Jim Everett* | 1986 | QB | Dave Krieg | 1981 | QB | Troy Aikman | 1989 |
| HB | Gale Sayers | 1965 | QB | Jon Kitna | 1998 | HB | Jerome Bettis | 1993 | HB | Terrell Davis | 1995 |
| HB | Bobby Mitchell | 1958 | HB | Curtis Martin | 1995 | HB | John Riggins | 1971 | HB | LeRoy Kelly* | 1964 |
| HB | Lawrence McCutcheon | 1973 | HB | William Andrews | 1979 | HB | Napoleon Kaufman | 1995 | HB | Charlie Garner | 1994 |
| HB | Ernie Green | 1962 | HB | Ricky Williams (1) | 2002 | HB | Barry Foster | 1990 | HB | Keith Lincoln | 1961 |
| HB | Mike Pruitt* | 1976 | HB | Gerald Riggs | 1982 | HB | Dick Hoak | 1961 | HB | Dickie Post | 1967 |
| WR | Cliff Branch | 1972 | HB | Willis McGahee | 2004 | WR | Tim Brown | 1988 | HB | Duane Thomas | 1970 |
| WR | Mac Speedie | 1946 | WR | Anquan Boldin | 2003 | WR | Henry Ellard | 1983 | HB | Johnny Strzykalski | 1946 |
| WR | Webster Slaughter | 1986 | WR | Gary Clark | 1985 | WR | Charlie Joiner | 1969 | WR | Torry Holt | 1999 |
| WR | Gary Collins - x | 1962 | WR | Joey Galloway | 1995 | WR | Laveranues Coles (2) | 2005 | WR | Bob Hayes | 1965 |
| WR | Darrell Brewster | 1952 | WR | Mike Quick* | 1982 | WR | Santonio Holmes | 2006 | WR | Gene Washington | 1969 |
| WR | Roy Williams (1) | 2006 | WR | Anthony Carter | 1985 | WR | Carl Pickens | 1992 | WR | Haven Moses | 1968 |
| WR | Dave Logan | 1976 | WR | Frank Sanders | 1995 | WR | Antwaan Randle El | 2002 | WR | Otis Taylor | 1965 |
| WR | Ricky Feacher | 1978 | WR | Darnay Scott | 1994 | TE | Joe Senser | 1980 | WR | Buddy Dial | 1959 |
| TE | Ozzie Newsome | 1978 | WR | Bob Mann | 1948 | TE | Bud Grant (1) | 1952 | TE | Dave Kocourek | 1960 |
| TE | Gordie Soltau | 1950 | TE | Mike Ditka | 1961 | TE | Heath Miller | 2005 | TE | Jimmie Giles | 1977 |
| TE | Ray Poole | 1947 | TE | Charle Young | 1973 | K | Adam Vinatieri | 1996 | TE | Henry Childs | 1975 |
| K | Phil Dawson | 1999 | TE | Walter White | 1975 | P | Tom Rouen | 1993 | K | John Carney | 1990 |
| P | Gary Collins - x | 1962 | K | Todd Peterson | 1995 | OL | Dallas Texans | 1962 | P | Sammy Baugh - x | 1941 |
| OL | San Diego Chargers | 1963 | P | Bobby Joe Green* | 1960 | D | Minnesota Vikings | 1969 | OL | New England Patriots | 1976 |
| D | Baltimore Ravens | 2006 | P | Dean McAdams | 1941 | ST | Los Angeles Rams | 1985 | D | Chicago Bears | 1985 |
| ST | Cleveland Browns | 1994 | OL | San Francisco 49ers | 1992 | ST | St. Louis Cardinals | 1986 | |||
| NOTE - NO 2 YEAR PLAYER | D | Cleveland Browns | 1954 | NOTE - NO 1 YEAR PLAYER | |||||||
| ST | Seattle Seahawks | 2000 | NOTE - NO 2 YEAR PLAYER | ||||||||
| San Diego Scream'n Daemons | HOUSTON K-CARS | OAKLAND OUTLAWS | MISERY RIDERS | ||||||||
| POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year |
| QB | Fran Tarkenton | 1961 | QB | Johnny Unitas | 1956 | QB | Steve Young | 1985 | QB | Dan Fouts | 1973 |
| QB | Jeff Garcia | 1999 | QB | Frankie Albert | 1946 | QB | Joe Namath | 1965 | QB | Steve Beuerlein | 1988 |
| QB | Bart Starr | 1956 | QB | Earl Morrall | 1956 | QB | Bob Griese | 1967 | QB | Charlie Conerly | 1948 |
| HB | Joe Perry | 1948 | QB | Greg Cook | 1969 | QB | Jim Zorn | 1976 | QB | Vince Young | 2006 |
| HB | James Brooks | 1981 | HB | Walter Payton | 1975 | HB | Earl Campbell | 1978 | HB | O.J. Simpson | 1969 |
| HB | Wendell Tyler | 1977 | HB | Lenny Moore | 1956 | HB | Fred Taylor | 1998 | HB | Curt Warner | 1983 |
| HB | Terry Metcalf | 1973 | HB | Marion Motley | 1946 | HB | James Wilder | 1981 | HB | Natrone Means | 1993 |
| HB | Bo Jackson | 1987 | HB | Maurice Jones-Drew | 2006 | HB | Joe Cribbs | 1980 | HB | John Brockington | 1971 |
| HB | Dan Towler* | 1950 | HB | Tank Younger | 1949 | HB | Tom Rathman | 1986 | HB | Rueben Mayes | 1986 |
| HB | Marv Hubbard* | 1969 | WR | Lance Alworth | 1962 | WR | Michael Irvin | 1988 | WR | Cris Carter | 1987 |
| HB | Stump Mitchell | 1981 | WR | Art Powell* | 1959 | WR | Raymond Berry | 1955 | WR | Herman Moore | 1991 |
| WR | Jerry Rice | 1985 | WR | Santana Moss (2) | 2005 | WR | Chad Johnson | 2001 | WR | Brett Perriman (1) | 1995 |
| WR | Marvin Harrison | 1996 | WR | Marcus Robinson | 1999 | WR | Lynn Swann | 1974 | WR | Chris Chambers | 2001 |
| WR | Jimmy Smith | 1995 | WR | Bill Brooks | 1986 | WR | John Stallworth | 1974 | WR | J.T. Smith | 1979 |
| WR | Todd Christensen* | 1981 | WR | Rich Caster | 1970 | WR | Jack Snow | 1965 | WR | Bob Boyd | 1950 |
| WR | Donald Driver (2) | 2005 | TE | Frank Wycheck | 1993 | TE | Dan Ross | 1979 | TE | Todd Heap | 2001 |
| WR | Willie Gault | 1983 | TE | Jerry Smith | 1965 | TE | Billy Joe DuPree | 1973 | TE | Desmond Clark | 1999 |
| WR | Mel Gray | 1971 | TE | Leon Clarke | 1956 | TE | Clint Didier | 1982 | TE | Eric Johnson | 2001 |
| TE | Shannon Sharpe | 1990 | TE | Fran Polsfoot (1) | 1951 | K | Mike Hollis | 1995 | K | Brad Daluiso | 1994 |
| TE | Riley Odoms | 1972 | TE | Willie Frazier* | 1964 | P | Bryan Barker | 1990 | P | Mark Royals | 1990 |
| TE | Bill Dewell (1) | 1946 | K | David Akers | 2000 | OL | Miami Dolphins | 1973 | OL | Indianapolis Colts | 2004 |
| K | Rian Lindell | 2000 | P | Larry Barnes | 1957 | D | Baltimore Ravens | 2000 | D | Philadelphia Eagles | 1991 |
| P | Rick Tuten | 1990 | OL | Buffalo Bills | 1973 | ST | Oakland Raiders | 1964 | ST | Buffalo Bills | 2005 |
| OL | Kansas City Chiefs | 1966 | D | Green Bay Packers | 1996 | NOTE - NO 1 YEAR PLAYER | NOTE - NO 2 YEAR PLAYER | ||||
| D | Philadelphia Eagles | 1954 | ST | Oakland Raiders | 1975 | NOTE - NO 2 YEAR PLAYER | |||||
| ST | Washington Redskins | 1962 | |||||||||
| PHILLY PHARMHANDS | WASH. SALMONBELLIES | NY/NJ MACHINE | BALTIMORE DRAGONS | ||||||||
| POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year |
| QB | Randall Cunningham | 1985 | QB | Warren Moon | 1984 | QB | Joe Montana | 1979 | QB | Bernie Kosar | 1985 |
| QB | Matt Hasselbeck (2) | 2005 | QB | Bobby Layne | 1948 | QB | Rich Gannon (2) | 2002 | QB | Len Dawson | 1957 |
| QB | Jim Hart | 1967 | QB | Vinny Testaverde | 1987 | QB | Steve DeBerg | 1978 | QB | John Brodie | 1957 |
| HB | Robert Smith | 1993 | HB | Jim Brown | 1957 | HB | Tiki Barber | 1997 | QB | John Hadl | 1962 |
| HB | Eddie George | 1996 | HB | Lydell Mitchell | 1972 | HB | Jamal Lewis | 2000 | QB | Norm Snead | 1961 |
| HB | Rudi Johnson (1) | 2005 | HB | Herschel Walker | 1986 | HB | Corey Dillon | 1997 | HB | Jim Nance | 1965 |
| HB | Travis Henry | 2001 | HB | Keith Byars | 1986 | HB | John David Crow | 1958 | HB | Larry Csonka | 1968 |
| HB | Mark Van Eeghan | 1975 | HB | Earnest Byner | 1984 | HB | Garrison Hearst | 1993 | HB | Billy Sims | 1980 |
| WR | Charley Hennigan | 1960 | HB | Larry Centers | 1991 | WR | Art Monk | 1980 | HB | Larry Brown | 1969 |
| WR | Ken Burrough | 1970 | WR | Sterling Sharpe | 1988 | WR | Steve Smith | 2001 | HB | Dick Bass | 1960 |
| WR | Antonio Freeman | 1995 | WR | Isaac Bruce | 1994 | WR | Amani Toomer | 1996 | HB | Tommy McDonald | 1957 |
| WR | Alfred Jenkins | 1975 | WR | Harold Carmichael | 1971 | WR | Terry Glenn | 1996 | WR | Harold Jackson | 1969 |
| WR | Ken Kavanaugh | 1941 | WR | Stanley Morgan | 1977 | WR | Robert Brooks (1) | 1995 | WR | Dwight Clark | 1979 |
| WR | Dante Lavelli | 1946 | WR | David Boston (1) | 2001 | WR | Derrick Mason | 1997 | WR | Fred Biletnikoff | 1965 |
| TE | Pete Pihos | 1947 | WR | Andre Johnson (2) | 2005 | TE | Antonio Gates | 2003 | WR | Jerome Barkum | 1972 |
| TE | Ted Kwalick | 1969 | TE | Pete Retzlaff | 1956 | TE | Jason Witten | 2003 | TE | Charlie Sanders | 1968 |
| TE | Jack Russell | 1946 | TE | Bob Tucker | 1970 | TE | Jim Mutscheller | 1954 | TE | Steve Jordan | 1982 |
| TE | Fred Arbanas | 1962 | TE | Marv Cook | 1989 | TE | Rickey Dudley | 1996 | TE | Ron Kramer | 1957 |
| K | John Kasay | 1991 | K | Norm Johnson | 1982 | K | Al Del Greco | 1984 | K | Mike Vanderjagt | 1998 |
| P | Tommy Davis | 1959 | P | Todd Sauerbrun | 1995 | P | Ray Guy | 1973 | P | Don Chandler | 1956 |
| OL | Los Angeles Rams | 1953 | OL | Kansas City Chiefs | 2002 | OL | Cleveland Browns | 1947 | OL | Green Bay Packers | 1961 |
| D | Cleveland Browns | 1946 | D | Baltimore Colts | 1971 | D | Chicago Bears | 1986 | D | Chicago Bears | 1963 |
| ST | New York Jets | 2002 | ST | Kansas City Chiefs | 2003 | ST | Chicago Bears | 1967 | ST | Seattle Seahawks | 1983 |
| NOTE - NO 1 YEAR PLAYER | |||||||||||
| NOTE - NO 2 YEAR PLAYER | |||||||||||
| DETROIT ICEMEN | MINNESOTA MUDDERS | JACKSONVILLE SKYNYRDS | DALLAS TEXANS (N) | ||||||||
| POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year |
| QB | Kurt Warner | 1999 | QB | Jim Kelly | 1986 | QB | Sonny Jurgensen | 1957 | QB | Daunte Culpepper | 2000 |
| QB | Marc Bulger (2) | 2005 | QB | Ken O'Brien | 1984 | QB | Ken Anderson | 1971 | QB | Byron Leftwich | 2003 |
| QB | Darryl Lamonica | 1963 | QB | Bert Jones | 1973 | QB | Norm Van Brocklin (2) | 1959 | QB | Koy Detmer | 1998 |
| HB | Tony Dorsett | 1977 | HB | Barry Sanders | 1989 | QB | Johnny Lujack | 1948 | HB | Ottis Anderson | 1979 |
| HB | Greg Pruitt | 1973 | HB | Freeman McNeil | 1981 | QB | Brian Griese | 1999 | HB | Mike Garrett | 1966 |
| HB | Eric Metcalf | 1989 | HB | Chuck Foreman | 1973 | QB | Jeff George* | 1990 | HB | Steven Jackson | 2004 |
| HB | S.D. Jones | 1946 | HB | Wilbert Montgomery | 1977 | HB | Emmitt Smith | 1990 | HB | Ricky Bell | 1977 |
| WR | Brian Blades | 1988 | HB | Sam Cunningham | 1973 | HB | Hugh McElhenny | 1952 | HB | Brian Westbrook | 2002 |
| WR | Larry Fitzgerald | 2004 | WR | Andre Reed | 1985 | HB | Otis Armstrong (1) | 1974 | HB | Lamont Jordan | 2001 |
| WR | Haywood Jeffires | 1987 | WR | Harlon Hill | 1954 | HB | Clem Daniels | 1961 | WR | Rod Smith | 1995 |
| WR | Tony Hill | 1977 | WR | Wesley Walker | 1977 | HB | George McAfee | 1941 | WR | Billy W.S. Johnson (1) | 1985 |
| WR | Jake Reed | 1992 | WR | Eddie Brown | 1985 | WR | Don Hutson | 1941 | WR | Nat Moore | 1974 |
| WR | Ahmad Rashad | 1972 | WR | Flipper Anderson | 1988 | WR | Don Maynard* | 1958 | WR | Freddie Solomon | 1975 |
| WR | Braylon Edwards (1) | 2006 | WR | Bill Anderson | 1958 | WR | Irving Fryar | 1984 | WR | Louis Lipps | 1984 |
| WR | James Jett | 1993 | TE | Tony Gonzalez | 1997 | WR | Billy Howton | 1952 | WR | Ike Hilliard | 1998 |
| TE | Kellen Winslow | 1979 | TE | Ken Dilger | 1995 | WR | Danny Abramowicz | 1967 | TE | Jackie Smith | 1963 |
| TE | Dave Casper | 1974 | TE | David Hill | 1976 | WR | Dick Gordon | 1965 | TE | Tony McGee | 1993 |
| TE | Kellen Winslow II | 2006 | TE | Doug Cosbie | 1979 | TE | Tom Fears | 1948 | TE | Jermaine Wiggins | 2000 |
| K | Eddie Murray | 1980 | K | Gary Anderson | 1982 | TE | Brent Jones | 1987 | K | Pete Stoyanovich | 1989 |
| P | Yale Lary | 1952 | P | Shane Lechler | 2000 | TE | Leon Hart | 1950 | P | Craig Hentrich | 1994 |
| OL | Green Bay Packers | 1962 | OL | San Francisco 49ers | 1948 | K | Joe Maniaci | 1941 | OL | Cleveland Browns | 1966 |
| D | Chicago Bears | 1942 | D | Philadelphia Eagles | 1949 | K | Neil Rackers* | 2000 | D | New York Giants | 1951 |
| ST | Miami Dolphins | 1971 | ST | Baltimore Colts | 1968 | P | Horace Gillom | 1947 | ST | Miami Dolphins | 1983 |
| NOTE - NO 1 YEAR PLAYER | OL | Cleveland Browns | 1960 | NOTE - NO 2 YEAR PLAYER | |||||||
| NOTE - NO 2 YEAR PLAYER | D | San Francisco 49ers | 1995 | ||||||||
| ST | Pittsburgh Steelers | 1952 | |||||||||
| CALIFORNIA REDWOODS | OLYMPIA OLYMPIANS | GOLDEN GATE GIBBS | JUNEAU SUCKER HOLES | ||||||||
| POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year | POS | Player | Year |
| QB | Otto Graham | 1946 | QB | Carson Palmer (2) | 2005 | QB | Roger Staubach | 1969 | QB | Dan Marino | 1983 |
| QB | Boomer Esiason | 1984 | QB | Donovan McNabb* | 1999 | QB | Joe Theismann (2) | 1984 | QB | Neil Lomax (2) | 1987 |
| QB | Don Meredith* | 1960 | QB | Aaron Brooks | 2000 | QB | Phil Simms | 1979 | QB | David Carr | 2002 |
| QB | Lynn Dickey (2) | 1984 | QB | Mark Rypien | 1988 | HB | Thurman Thomas | 1988 | HB | Shaun Alexander | 2000 |
| HB | Eric Dickerson | 1983 | HB | LaDainian Tomlinson | 2001 | HB | Crazy Legs Hirsch | 1946 | HB | Clinton Portis | 2002 |
| HB | Mercury Morris | 1969 | HB | Ricky Watters | 1992 | HB | Frank Gore (1) | 2006 | HB | George Rogers | 1981 |
| HB | Deuce McAllister | 2001 | HB | Cloyce Box | 1949 | HB | Chuck Muncie | 1976 | HB | Cookie Gilchrist | 1962 |
| HB | Calvin Hill | 1969 | HB | Ahman Green (1) | 2003 | HB | John Henry Johnson | 1954 | HB | Michael Bennett | 2001 |
| HB | Stephen Davis | 1996 | HB | Terry Allen | 1991 | WR | Wes Chandler | 1978 | WR | Steve Largent | 1976 |
| HB | Billy Cannon | 1960 | HB | Mike Anderson | 2000 | WR | Drew Pearson | 1973 | WR | Bill Groman | 1960 |
| WR | James Lofton | 1978 | WR | Cris Collinsworth | 1981 | WR | Donte' Stallworth | 2002 | WR | Mark Duper | 1983 |
| WR | Paul Warfield | 1964 | WR | John Jefferson | 1978 | WR | Roy Green | 1979 | WR | Mark Clayton | 1983 |
| WR | Jimmy Orr | 1958 | WR | Lionel Taylor* | 1959 | WR | John Taylor | 1987 | WR | Warren Wells | 1964 |
| WR | Gary Garrison | 1966 | WR | Darrell Jackson | 2000 | WR | Roger Carr | 1974 | WR | Anthony Miller | 1988 |
| WR | Sammy White | 1976 | WR | Charlie Brown | 1982 | WR | Michael Haynes | 1988 | WR | George Sauer | 1965 |
| WR | Don Norton | 1960 | WR | Isaac Curtis | 1973 | TE | Dave Parks | 1964 | TE | Jeremy Shockey | 2002 |
| TE | Raymond Chester | 1970 | WR | Kevin Johnson | 1999 | TE | Alge Crumpler | 2001 | TE | Paul Coffman | 1979 |
| TE | Jim Mitchell | 1969 | TE | John Mackey | 1963 | TE | Johnny Mitchell | 1992 | TE | Freddie Jones | 1997 |
| TE | Milt Morin | 1966 | TE | Bob Trumpy | 1968 | K | Jason Elam | 1993 | K | Ryan Longwell | 1997 |
| K | Jason Hanson | 1992 | TE | Willard Dewveal | 1959 | P | Reggie Roby | 1983 | P | Kay Eakin | 1941 |
| P | Greg Montgomery | 1988 | K | Kris Brown | 1999 | OL | Los Angeles Rams | 1951 | OL | Miami Dolphins | 1971 |
| OL | Miami Dolphins | 1972 | P | Jeff Burkett | 1947 | D | Minnesota Vikings | 1970 | D | New York Giants | 1959 |
| D | Philadelphia Eagles | 1948 | P | Pat Brady* | 1952 | ST | Carolina Panthers | 1996 | ST | Washington Redskins | 1957 |
| ST | Washington Redskins | 1963 | OL | Cleveland Browns | 1963 | NOTE - NO 1 YEAR PLAYER | |||||
| NOTE - NO 1 YEAR PLAYER | D | Washington Redskins | 1942 | ||||||||
| ST | Cleveland Browns | 1967 | |||||||||