| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| 2000 | Baltimore Ravens | D | #1 | 1 | Oakland Outlaws | All | $ 37.23 |
| Rookie | Dan Marino | QB | #2 | 2 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 17 | $ 100.45 |
| 2006 | Baltimore Ravens | D | #3 | 3 | Cleveland MoonDogs | All | $ 36.73 |
| 1942 | Chicago Bears | D | #4 | 4 | Detroit Icemen | All | $ 41.34 |
| 1948 | Chicago Bears | D | #5 | 5 | New England Razors | All | $ 37.49 |
| 1969 | Minnesota Vikings | D | #6 | 6 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | All | $ 37.64 |
| Rookie | Brett Favre | QB | #7 | 7 | The Flushing Flash | 15+ | $ 92.66 |
| Rookie | Barry Sanders | HB | #8 | 8 | Minnesota Mudders | 10 | $ 70.46 |
| 1951 | New York Giants | D | #9 | 9 | Dallas Texans (N) | All | $ 37.38 |
| Rookie | Marshall Faulk | HB | #10 | 10 | Dallas Texans (A) | 12 | $ 66.65 |
| 1951 | Los Angeles Rams | OL | #11 | 11 | Golden Gate Gibbs | All | $ 6.14 |
| Rookie | O.J. Simpson | HB | #12 | 12 | Misery Riders | 11 | $ 60.46 |
| 1963 | Cleveland Browns | OL | #13 | 13 | Olympia Olympians | All | $ 5.84 |
| Rookie | Peyton Manning | QB | #14 | 14 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 9+ | $ 62.36 |
| Rookie | Jim Brown | HB | #15 | 15 | Washington Salmonbellies | 9 | $ 70.46 |
| 1976 | Pittsburgh Steelers | D | #16 | 16 | Buffalo Curse | All | $ 35.93 |
| Rookie | Joe Montana | QB | #17 | 17 | NY/NJ Machine | 14 | $ 74.34 |
| 2002 | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | D | #18 | 18 | Miami Finest | All | $ 37.14 |
| 1963 | Chicago Bears | D | #19 | 19 | Baltimore Dragons | All | $ 36.31 |
| 1953 | Los Angeles Rams | OL | #20 | 20 | Pottsville Maroons | All | $ 5.88 |
| Rookie | Otto Graham | QB | #21 | 21 | California Redwoods | 10 | $ 55.70 |
| Rookie | Emmitt Smith | HB | #22 | 22 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 15 | $ 82.79 |
| Rookie | Walter Payton | HB | #23 | 23 | Houston K-Cars | 13 | $ 84.73 |
| Rookie | Jerry Rice | WR | #24 | 24 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 19 | $ 42.76 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Fran Tarkenton | QB | #1 | 25 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 18 | $ 105.13 |
| Rookie | Johnny Unitas | QB | #2 | 26 | Houston K-Cars | 18 | $ 85.43 |
| 1960 | Cleveland Browns | OL | #3 | 27 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | All | $ 5.94 |
| Rookie | Eric Dickerson | HB | #4 | 28 | California Redwoods | 11 | $ 57.58 |
| 1946 | Cleveland Browns | D | #5 | 29 | Pottsville Maroons | All | $ 36.16 |
| 1961 | Green Bay Packers | OL | #6 | 30 | Baltimore Dragons | All | $ 5.71 |
| Rookie | Marcus Allen | HB | #7 | 31 | Miami Finest | 16 | $ 71.60 |
| 1986 | Chicago Bears | D | #8 | 32 | NY/NJ Machine | All | $ 35.28 |
| Rookie | John Elway | QB | #9 | 33 | Buffalo Curse | 16 | $ 82.51 |
| 1971 | Baltimore Colts | D | #10 | 34 | Washington Salmonbellies | All | $ 35.59 |
| Rookie | Curtis Martin | HB | #11 | 35 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 11 | $ 63.88 |
| Rookie | LaDainian Tomlinson | HB | #12 | 36 | Olympia Olympians | 6+ | $ 42.52 |
| Rookie | Dan Fouts | QB | #13 | 37 | Misery Riders | 15 | $ 76.10 |
| 1970 | Minnesota Vikings | D | #14 | 38 | Golden Gate Gibbs | All | $ 35.50 |
| Rookie | Sammy Baugh | QB/P | #15 | 39 | Dallas Texans (A) | 12 | $ 66.23 |
| Rookie | Daunte Culpepper | QB | #16 | 40 | Dallas Texans (N) | 7+ | $ 37.63 |
| 1949 | Philadelphia Eagles | D | #17 | 41 | Minnesota Mudders | All | $ 37.08 |
| Rookie | Roger Craig | HB | #18 | 42 | The Flushing Flash | 11 | $ 51.26 |
| 1962 | Dallas Texans | OL | #19 | 43 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | All | $ 5.65 |
| Rookie | Edgerrin James | HB | #20 | 44 | New England Razors | 8+ | $ 46.83 |
| Rookie | Tony Dorsett | HB | #21 | 45 | Detroit Icemen | 12 | $ 67.98 |
| Rookie | Gale Sayers | HB | #22 | 46 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 5 | $ 30.01 |
| Rookie | Shaun Alexander | HB | #23 | 47 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 7+ | $ 37.46 |
| Rookie | Steve Young | QB | #24 | 48 | Oakland Outlaws | 14 | $ 64.76 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Earl Campbell | HB | #1 | 49 | Oakland Outlaws | 8 | $ 41.81 |
| Rookie | Steve Largent | WR | #2 | 50 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 14 | $ 27.50 |
| 1963 | San Diego Chargers | OL | #3 | 51 | Cleveland MoonDogs | All | $ 5.43 |
| 1962 | Green Bay Packers | OL | #4 | 52 | Detroit Icemen | All | $ 5.55 |
| 1954 | Los Angeles Rams | OL | #5 | 53 | New England Razors | All | $ 5.68 |
| Rookie | Tom Brady | QB | #6 | 54 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 6+ | $ 35.26 |
| Rookie | Randy Moss | WR | #7 | 55 | The Flushing Flash | 9+ | $ 19.53 |
| Rookie | Tony Gonzalez | TE | #8 | 56 | Minnesota Mudders | 10+ | $ 19.12 |
| Rookie | Ottis Anderson | HB | #9 | 57 | Dallas Texans (N) | 13 | $ 54.18 |
| Rookie | Torry Holt | WR | #10 | 58 | Dallas Texans (A) | 8+ | $ 19.19 |
| Rookie | Roger Staubach | QB | #11 | 59 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 11 | $ 47.80 |
| 2004 | Indianapolis Colts | OL | #12 | 60 | Misery Riders | All | $ 5.37 |
| 05-06 | Carson Palmer | QB | #13 | 61 | Olympia Olympians | 2 | $ 13.52 |
| Rookie | Anquan Boldin | WR | #14 | 62 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 4+ | $ 8.70 |
| Rookie | Warren Moon | QB | #15 | 63 | Washington Salmonbellies | 16 | $ 78.80 |
| 1941 | Chicago Bears | OL | #16 | 64 | Buffalo Curse | All | $ 5.19 |
| Rookie | Tiki Barber | HB | #17 | 65 | NY/NJ Machine | 10 | $ 55.80 |
| Rookie | Mark Brunell | QB | #18 | 66 | Miami Finest | 11 | $ 51.83 |
| 1983 | Seattle Seahawks | ST | #19 | 67 | Baltimore Dragons | All | $ 5.17 |
| Rookie | Randall Cunningham | QB | #20 | 68 | Pottsville Maroons | 15 | $ 57.27 |
| 1948 | Philadelphia Eagles | D | #21 | 69 | California Redwoods | All | $ 34.72 |
| Rookie | Sonny Jurgensen | QB | #22 | 70 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 18 | $ 67.35 |
| 1973 | Buffalo Bills | OL | #23 | 71 | Houston K-Cars | All | $ 5.46 |
| Rookie | Marvin Harrison | WR | #24 | 72 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 11+ | $ 25.70 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Jimmy Smith | WR | #1 | 73 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 11 | $ 23.27 |
| Rookie | Lance Alworth | WR | #2 | 74 | Houston K-Cars | 11 | $ 20.47 |
| Rookie | Don Hutson | WR/K | #3 | 75 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 5 | $ 16.22 |
| 1972 | Miami Dolphins | OL | #4 | 76 | California Redwoods | All | $ 5.30 |
| Rookie | Charley Hennigan | WR | #5 | 77 | Pottsville Maroons | 7 | $ 13.85 |
| Rookie | Mike Vanderjagt | K | #6 | 78 | Baltimore Dragons | 9+ | $ 29.51 |
| 2003 | Green Bay Packers | OL | #7 | 79 | Miami Finest | All | $ 5.36 |
| Rookie | Art Monk | WR | #8 | 80 | NY/NJ Machine | 15 | $ 28.18 |
| Rookie | Franco Harris | HB | #9 | 81 | Buffalo Curse | 13 | $ 66.23 |
| 2002 | Kansas City Cheifs | OL | #10 | 82 | Washington Salmonbellies | All | $ 5.37 |
| 1954 | Cleveland Browns | D | #11 | 83 | Cincinnati Bungholes | All | $ 35.53 |
| 1942 | Washington Redskins | D | #12 | 84 | Olympia Olympians | All | $ 34.30 |
| Rookie | Curt Warner | HB | #13 | 85 | Misery Riders | 7 | $ 32.88 |
| Rookie | Thurman Thomas | HB | #14 | 86 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 13 | $ 62.62 |
| Rookie | Terrell Davis | HB | #15 | 87 | Dallas Texans (A) | 7 | $ 33.82 |
| Rookie | Rod Smith | WR | #16 | 88 | Dallas Texans (N) | 12+ | $ 22.67 |
| Rookie | Gary Anderson | K | #17 | 89 | Minnesota Mudders | 23 | $ 67.37 |
| Rookie | Terrell Owens | WR | #18 | 90 | The Flushing Flash | 11+ | $ 22.06 |
| Rookie | Tim Brown | WR | #19 | 91 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 16 | $ 30.50 |
| Rookie | Jeff Wilkins | K | #20 | 92 | New England Razors | 12+ | $ 38.54 |
| Rookie | Kurt Warner | QB | #21 | 93 | Detroit Icemen | 7+ | $ 32.18 |
| Rookie | Brian Sipe | QB | #22 | 94 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 10 | $ 39.86 |
| 1971 | Miami Dolphins | OL | #23 | 95 | Juneau Sucker Holes | All | $ 5.24 |
| Rookie | Michael Irvin | WR | #24 | 96 | Oakland Outlaws | 12 | $ 22.05 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| 1973 | Miami Dolphins | OL | #1 | 97 | Oakland Outlaws | All | $ 5.22 |
| 1959 | New York Giants | D | #2 | 98 | Juneau Sucker Holes | All | $ 34.49 |
| Rookie | Ozzie Newsome | TE | #3 | 99 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 13 | $ 20.96 |
| Rookie | Kellen Winslow Sr. | TE | #4 | 100 | Detroit Icemen | 9 | $ 15.92 |
| Rookie | Drew Bledsoe | QB | #5 | 101 | New England Razors | 13 | $ 68.61 |
| 1985 | Los Angeles Rams | ST | #6 | 102 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | All | $ 5.13 |
| 1950 | Cleveland Browns | D | #7 | 103 | The Flushing Flash | All | $ 35.38 |
| Rookie | Jim Kelly | QB | #8 | 104 | Minnesota Mudders | 11 | $ 55.59 |
| 1985 | Billy "White Shoes" Johnson | WR | #9 | 105 | Dallas Texans (N) | 1 | $ 1.86 |
| 1985 | Chicago Bears | D | #10 | 106 | Dallas Texans (A) | All | $ 34.75 |
| Rookie | Crazy Legs Hirsch | HB/WR | #11 | 107 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 12 | $ 23.39 |
| 1991 | Philadelphia Eagles | D | #12 | 108 | Misery Riders | All | $ 34.89 |
| Rookie | Cris Collinsworth | WR | #13 | 109 | Olympia Olympians | 8 | $ 14.09 |
| Rookie | William Andrews | HB | #14 | 110 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 6 | $ 35.35 |
| Rookie | Sterling Sharpe | WR | #15 | 111 | Washington Salmonbellies | 7 | $ 16.17 |
| Rookie | Priest Holmes | HB | #16 | 112 | Buffalo Curse | 8+ | $ 39.56 |
| 1947 | Cleveland Browns | OL | #17 | 113 | NY/NJ Machine | All | $ 5.07 |
| 05-06 | Larry Johnson | HB | #18 | 114 | Miami Finest | 2 | $ 15.07 |
| Rookie | Bernie Kosar | QB | #19 | 115 | Baltimore Dragons | 10 | $ 36.72 |
| Rookie | Pete Pihos | TE | #20 | 116 | Pottsville Maroons | 9 | $ 15.64 |
| Rookie | James Lofton | WR | #21 | 117 | California Redwoods | 16 | $ 27.70 |
| Rookie | Tom Fears | TE | #22 | 118 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 8 | $ 14.78 |
| Rookie | Lenny Moore | HB | #23 | 119 | Houston K-Cars | 12 | $ 48.97 |
| Rookie | Joe Perry | HB | #24 | 120 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 16 | $ 71.58 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Shannon Sharpe | TE | #1 | 121 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 14 | $ 22.34 |
| 1996 | Green Bay Packers | D | #2 | 122 | Houston K-Cars | All | $ 35.10 |
| Rookie | Don Maynard | WR | #3 | 123 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 14 | $ 24.51 |
| Rookie | Paul Warfield | WR | #4 | 124 | California Redwoods | 12 | $ 19.29 |
| Rookie | Robert Smith | HB | #5 | 125 | Pottsville Maroons | 8 | $ 32.95 |
| Rookie | Jim Nance | HB | #6 | 126 | Baltimore Dragons | 8 | $ 32.22 |
| Rookie | Roman Gabriel | QB | #7 | 127 | Miami Finest | 15 | $ 64.73 |
| Rookie | Jamal Lewis | HB | #8 | 128 | NY/NJ Machine | 6+ | $ 32.60 |
| Rookie | Mark Bavaro | TE | #9 | 129 | Buffalo Curse | 9 | $ 11.42 |
| Rookie | Isaac Bruce | WR | #10 | 130 | Washington Salmonbellies | 13+ | $ 25.01 |
| Rookie | Mike Ditka | TE | #11 | 131 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 12 | $ 15.16 |
| Rookie | Ricky Watters | HB | #12 | 132 | Olympia Olympians | 10 | $ 54.20 |
| Rookie | Cris Carter | WR | #13 | 133 | Misery Riders | 16 | $ 29.37 |
| Rookie | Wes Chandler | WR | #14 | 134 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 11 | $ 18.94 |
| 1976 | New England Patriots | OL | #15 | 135 | Dallas Texans (A) | All | $ 5.20 |
| Rookie | Pete Stoyanovich | K | #16 | 136 | Dallas Texans (N) | 11 | $ 34.00 |
| 1948 | San Francisco 49ers | OL | #17 | 137 | Minnesota Mudders | All | $ 5.03 |
| 1949 | Philadelphia Eagles | OL | #18 | 138 | The Flushing Flash | All | $ 5.30 |
| Rookie | Adam Vinatieri | K | #19 | 139 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 11+ | $ 34.61 |
| Rookie | Bob Hayes | WR | #20 | 140 | New England Razors | 11 | $ 15.90 |
| Rookie | Brian Blades | WR | #21 | 141 | Detroit Icemen | 11 | $ 16.92 |
| Rookie | Bobby Mitchell | HB/WR | #22 | 142 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 11 | $ 34.49 |
| Rookie | Bill Groman | WR | #23 | 143 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 5 | $ 7.00 |
| Rookie | Joe Namath | QB | #24 | 144 | Oakland Outlaws | 13 | $ 50.27 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Raymond Berry | WR | #1 | 145 | Oakland Outlaws | 13 | $ 22.69 |
| Rookie | Mark Duper | WR | #2 | 146 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 10 | $ 17.43 |
| Rookie | Cecil Isbell | QB | #3 | 147 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 2 | $ 12.87 |
| Rookie | Larry Fitzgerald | WR | #4 | 148 | Detroit Icemen | 3 | $ 6.15 |
| 2002 | New Orleans Saints | ST | #5 | 149 | New England Razors | All | $ 5.13 |
| Rookie | Henry Ellard | WR | #6 | 150 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 16 | $ 26.85 |
| Rookie | Charley Taylor | HB/WR | #7 | 151 | The Flushing Flash | 13 | $ 30.54 |
| Rookie | Andre Reed | WR | #8 | 152 | Minnesota Mudders | 16 | $ 28.01 |
| Rookie | Jackie Smith | TE/P | #9 | 153 | Dallas Texans (N) | 15 | $ 23.02 |
| Rookie | Dave Kocourek | TE | #10 | 154 | Dallas Texans (A) | 9 | $ 10.52 |
| Rookie | Jason Elam | K | #11 | 155 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 14+ | $ 44.59 |
| Rookie | Herman Moore | WR | #12 | 156 | Misery Riders | 11 | $ 18.44 |
| Rookie | Cloyce Box | HB/TE | #13 | 157 | Olympia Olympians | 5 | $ 7.00 |
| 1992 | San Francisco 49ers | OL | #14 | 158 | Cincinnati Bungholes | All | $ 5.06 |
| Rookie | Harold Carmichael | WR | #15 | 159 | Washington Salmonbellies | 13 | $ 22.74 |
| Rookie | Morten Andersen | K | #16 | 160 | Buffalo Curse | 23+ | $ 72.25 |
| Rookie | Steve Smith | WR | #17 | 161 | NY/NJ Machine | 5+ | $ 9.27 |
| Rookie | Dave Middleton | WR | #18 | 162 | Miami Finest | 7 | $ 9.90 |
| Rookie | Harold Jackson | WR | #19 | 163 | Baltimore Dragons | 14 | $ 24.14 |
| Rookie | Ken Burrough | WR | #20 | 164 | Pottsville Maroons | 11 | $ 17.25 |
| Rookie | Raymond Chester | TE | #21 | 165 | California Redwoods | 12 | $ 14.56 |
| Rookie | Hugh McElhenny | HB | #22 | 166 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 13 | $ 37.41 |
| Rookie | Art Powell | WR | #23 | 167 | Houston K-Cars | 9 | $ 16.51 |
| Rookie | Todd Christensen | WR/TE | #24 | 168 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 8 | $ 13.61 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | James Brooks | HB | #1 | 169 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 12 | $ 52.28 |
| 1975 | Oakland Raiders | ST | #2 | 170 | Houston K-Cars | All | $ 5.12 |
| Rookie | Ken Anderson | QB | #3 | 171 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 15 | $ 65.98 |
| Rookie | Jason Hanson | K | #4 | 172 | California Redwoods | 15+ | $ 50.33 |
| Rookie | Eddie George | HB | #5 | 173 | Pottsville Maroons | 9 | $ 44.96 |
| Rookie | Len Dawson | QB | #6 | 174 | Baltimore Dragons | 18 | $ 56.62 |
| 46-47 | Jim Benton | WR | #7 | 175 | Miami Finest | 2 | $ 4.42 |
| Rookie | Antonio Gates | TE | #8 | 176 | NY/NJ Machine | 4 | $ 7.12 |
| Rookie | Y.A. Tittle | QB | #9 | 177 | Buffalo Curse | 17 | $ 76.77 |
| Rookie | Lydell Mitchell | HB | #10 | 178 | Washington Salmonbellies | 8 | $ 41.77 |
| 05-06 | Trent Green | QB | #11 | 179 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 2 | $ 8.20 |
| Rookie | Donovan McNabb | QB | #12 | 180 | Olympia Olympians | 8+ | $ 39.14 |
| 1995 | Brett Perriman | WR | #13 | 181 | Misery Riders | 1 | $ 2.60 |
| Rookie | Dave Parks | TE | #14 | 182 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 10 | $ 14.01 |
| Rookie | Gene Washington (SF) | WR | #15 | 183 | Dallas Texans (A) | 10 | $ 16.67 |
| 1966 | Cleveland Browns | OL | #16 | 184 | Dallas Texans (N) | All | $ 4.93 |
| Rookie | Harlon Hill | WR | #17 | 185 | Minnesota Mudders | 9 | $ 11.60 |
| Rookie | Jim Taylor | HB | #18 | 186 | The Flushing Flash | 10 | $ 51.81 |
| Rookie | Jerome Bettis | HB | #19 | 187 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 13 | $ 57.08 |
| Rookie | Ben Coates | TE | #20 | 188 | New England Razors | 10 | $ 13.63 |
| Rookie | Dave Casper | TE | #21 | 189 | Detroit Icemen | 11 | $ 13.42 |
| Rookie | Gordie Soltau | TE/K | #22 | 190 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 9 | $ 17.71 |
| Rookie | Clinton Portis | HB | #23 | 191 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 5+ | $ 28.31 |
| Rookie | Fred Taylor | HB | #24 | 192 | Oakland Outlaws | 8+ | $ 42.67 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Chad Johnson | WR | #1 | 193 | Oakland Outlaws | 6+ | $ 12.79 |
| Rookie | Jeremy Shockey | TE | #2 | 194 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 5+ | $ 8.23 |
| Rookie | Cliff Branch | WR | #3 | 195 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 13 | $ 20.64 |
| Rookie | Haywood Jeffires | WR | #4 | 196 | Detroit Icemen | 9 | $ 14.77 |
| Rookie | Eric Moulds | WR | #5 | 197 | New England Razors | 11+ | $ 19.96 |
| Rookie | John Riggins | HB | #6 | 198 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 14 | $ 59.81 |
| Rookie | Keith Jackson | TE | #7 | 199 | The Flushing Flash | 9 | $ 13.29 |
| Rookie | Shane Lechler | P | #8 | 200 | Minnesota Mudders | 7+ | $ 13.02 |
| Rookie | Mike Garrett | HB | #9 | 201 | Dallas Texans (N) | 8 | $ 36.75 |
| Rookie | LeRoy Kelly | HB | #10 | 202 | Dallas Texans (A) | 10 | $ 44.83 |
| 1996 | Carolina Panthers | ST | #11 | 203 | Golden Gate Gibbs | All | $ 5.12 |
| Rookie | Steve Beuerlein | QB | #12 | 204 | Misery Riders | 14 | $ 34.06 |
| Rookie | John Jefferson | WR | #13 | 205 | Olympia Olympians | 8 | $ 12.87 |
| Rookie | Gary Clark | WR | #14 | 206 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 11 | $ 21.52 |
| Rookie | Herschel Walker | HB | #15 | 207 | Washington Salmonbellies | 12 | $ 49.36 |
| Rookie | Ernest Givins | WR | #16 | 208 | Buffalo Curse | 10 | $ 17.49 |
| Rookie | Corey Dillon | HB | #17 | 209 | NY/NJ Machine | 10 | $ 49.57 |
| 1984 | Los Angeles Rams | ST | #18 | 210 | Miami Finest | All | $ 5.06 |
| Rookie | Larry Csonka | HB | #19 | 211 | Baltimore Dragons | 11 | $ 44.91 |
| 2005 | Rudi Johnson | HB | #20 | 212 | Pottsville Maroons | 1 | $ 5.80 |
| Rookie | Jimmy Orr | WR/P | #21 | 213 | California Redwoods | 13 | $ 19.07 |
| 1974 | Otis Armstong | HB | #22 | 214 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 1 | $ 8.33 |
| Rookie | Marion Motley | HB | #23 | 215 | Houston K-Cars | 9 | $ 34.72 |
| Rookie | Wendell Tyler | HB | #24 | 216 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 9 | $ 37.53 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Terry Metcalf | HB | #1 | 217 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 6 | $ 28.25 |
| 05-06 | Santana Moss | WR | #2 | 218 | Houston K-Cars | 2 | $ 4.16 |
| Rookie | Irving Fryar | WR | #3 | 219 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 17 | $ 27.35 |
| Rookie | Mercury Morris | HB | #4 | 220 | California Redwoods | 8 | $ 25.28 |
| Rookie | Antonio Freeman | WR | #5 | 221 | Pottsville Maroons | 9 | $ 14.46 |
| Rookie | Dwight Clark | WR | #6 | 222 | Baltimore Dragons | 9 | $ 16.24 |
| Rookie | Nick Lowery | K | #7 | 223 | Miami Finest | 17 | $ 54.48 |
| Rookie | Ray Guy | P | #8 | 224 | NY/NJ Machine | 14 | $ 19.54 |
| Rookie | Reggie Wayne | WR | #9 | 225 | Buffalo Curse | 6+ | $ 11.21 |
| Rookie | Bob Tucker | TE | #10 | 226 | Washington Salmonbellies | 11 | $ 15.59 |
| Rookie | Charle Young | TE | #11 | 227 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 13 | $ 15.83 |
| Rookie | John Mackey | TE | #12 | 228 | Olympia Olympians | 10 | $ 13.27 |
| 2005 | Buffalo Bills | ST | #13 | 229 | Misery Riders | All | $ 5.03 |
| 84-85 | Joe Theismann | QB | #14 | 230 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 2 | $ 8.17 |
| Rookie | John Carney | K | #15 | 231 | Dallas Texans (A) | 16+ | $ 50.79 |
| Rookie | Nat Moore | WR | #16 | 232 | Dallas Texans (N) | 13 | $ 19.16 |
| 1968 | Baltimore Colts | ST | #17 | 233 | Minnesota Mudders | All | $ 4.99 |
| Rookie | Matt Stover | K | #18 | 234 | The Flushing Flash | 16+ | $ 50.77 |
| Rookie | Charlie Joiner | WR | #19 | 235 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 18 | $ 27.71 |
| Rookie | Keyshawn Johnson | WR | #20 | 236 | New England Razors | 11 | $ 21.83 |
| Rookie | Greg Pruitt | HB | #21 | 237 | Detroit Icemen | 11 | $ 40.39 |
| Rookie | Mac Speedie | WR | #22 | 238 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 7 | $ 13.44 |
| Rookie | George Rogers | HB | #23 | 239 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 7 | $ 31.54 |
| Rookie | Dan Ross | TE | #24 | 240 | Oakland Outlaws | 7 | $ 9.67 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| 1964 | Oakland Raiders | ST | #1 | 241 | Oakland Outlaws | All | $ 5.04 |
| 87-88 | Neil Lomax | QB | #2 | 242 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 2 | $ 11.64 |
| Rookie | Webster Slaughter | WR | #3 | 243 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 12 | $ 17.64 |
| Rookie | Tony Hill | WR | #4 | 244 | Detroit Icemen | 10 | $ 17.02 |
| 05-06 | Drew Brees | QB | #5 | 245 | New England Razors | 2 | $ 13.70 |
| Rookie | Michael Vick | QB | #6 | 246 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 6+ | $ 21.53 |
| Rookie | Rob Moore | WR | #7 | 247 | The Flushing Flash | 10 | $ 19.17 |
| Rookie | Wesley Walker | WR | #8 | 248 | Minnesota Mudders | 13 | $ 17.80 |
| Rookie | Tony McGee | TE | #9 | 249 | Dallas Texans (N) | 10 | $ 10.85 |
| Rookie | Sid Luckman | QB/P | #10 | 250 | Dallas Texans (A) | 10 | $ 40.71 |
| 2006 | Frank Gore | HB | #11 | 251 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 1 | $ 7.91 |
| Rookie | Todd Heap | TE | #12 | 252 | Misery Riders | 6+ | $ 8.65 |
| 2003 | Ahman Green | HB | #13 | 253 | Olympia Olympians | 1 | $ 7.99 |
| 2000 | Seattle Seahawks | ST | #14 | 254 | Cincinnati Bungholes | All | $ 4.86 |
| Rookie | Bobby Layne | QB/K | #15 | 255 | Washington Salmonbellies | 15 | $ 71.66 |
| Rookie | Jay Novacek | TE | #16 | 256 | Buffalo Curse | 11 | $ 13.18 |
| 02-03 | Rich Gannon | QB | #17 | 257 | NY/NJ Machine | 2 | $ 10.27 |
| Rookie | Randy McMichael | TE | #18 | 258 | Miami Finest | 5+ | $ 8.08 |
| Rookie | Billy Sims | HB | #19 | 259 | Baltimore Dragons | 5 | $ 28.89 |
| Rookie | John Kasay | K | #20 | 260 | Pottsville Maroons | 14+ | $ 45.51 |
| 1963 | Washington Redskins | ST | #21 | 261 | California Redwoods | All | $ 5.00 |
| 59-60 | Norm Van Brocklin | QB/P | #22 | 262 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 2 | $ 15.51 |
| Rookie | David Akers | K | #23 | 263 | Houston K-Cars | 7+ | $ 22.74 |
| Rookie | Bo Jackson | HB | #24 | 264 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 4 | $ 14.85 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Dan Towler | HB | #1 | 265 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 6 | $ 26.01 |
| Rookie | Frank Wycheck | TE | #2 | 266 | Houston K-Cars | 11 | $ 14.22 |
| Rookie | Billy Howton | WR | #3 | 267 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 12 | $ 20.35 |
| Rookie | Greg Montgomery | P | #4 | 268 | California Redwoods | 9 | $ 14.21 |
| Rookie | Tommy Davis | K/P | #5 | 269 | Pottsville Maroons | 10 | $ 20.42 |
| Rookie | Charlie Sanders | TE | #6 | 270 | Baltimore Dragons | 10 | $ 13.99 |
| Rookie | Andre Rison | WR | #7 | 271 | Miami Finest | 12 | $ 21.55 |
| Rookie | Amani Toomer | WR | #8 | 272 | NY/NJ Machine | 11+ | $ 16.95 |
| Rookie | Neal Anderson | HB | #9 | 273 | Buffalo Curse | 8 | $ 35.97 |
| Rookie | Vinny Testaverde | QB | #10 | 274 | Washington Salmonbellies | 18 | $ 65.16 |
| Rookie | Joey Galloway | WR | #11 | 275 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 11+ | $ 19.27 |
| Rookie | Lionel Taylor | WR | #12 | 276 | Olympia Olympians | 10 | $ 16.90 |
| Rookie | Natrone Means | HB | #13 | 277 | Misery Riders | 7 | $ 23.87 |
| Rookie | Drew Pearson | WR | #14 | 278 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 11 | $ 19.32 |
| 1986 | St. Louis Cardinals | ST | #15 | 279 | Dallas Texans (A) | All | $ 4.81 |
| Rookie | Craig Hentrich | P | #16 | 280 | Dallas Texans (N) | 13+ | $ 18.90 |
| Rookie | Ken O'Brien | QB | #17 | 281 | Minnesota Mudders | 10 | $ 41.28 |
| Rookie | Mickey Shuler | TE | #18 | 282 | The Flushing Flash | 13 | $ 13.80 |
| Rookie | Tom Rouen | P | #19 | 283 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 13 | $ 19.47 |
| Rookie | Mushin Muhammad | WR | #20 | 284 | New England Razors | 11+ | $ 19.41 |
| 05-06 | Marc Bulger | QB | #21 | 285 | Detroit Icemen | 2 | $ 11.99 |
| Rookie | Milt Plum | QB | #22 | 286 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 12 | $ 36.25 |
| Rookie | Ryan Longwell | K | #23 | 287 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 10+ | $ 30.42 |
| Rookie | Bob Griese | QB | #24 | 288 | Oakland Outlaws | 14 | $ 48.13 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | James Wilder | HB | #1 | 289 | Oakland Outlaws | 10 | $ 38.55 |
| Rookie | Paul Coffman | TE | #2 | 290 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 9 | $ 11.82 |
| Rookie | Gary Collins | WR/P | #3 | 291 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 10 | $ 20.50 |
| Rookie | Kellen Winslow II | TE | #4 | 292 | Detroit Icemen | 1 | $ 2.09 |
| Rookie | Hines Ward | WR | #5 | 293 | New England Razors | 9+ | $ 16.94 |
| Rookie | Napoleon Kaufman | HB | #6 | 294 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 6 | $ 24.26 |
| Rookie | Al Toon | WR | #7 | 295 | The Flushing Flash | 8 | $ 14.46 |
| Rookie | Freeman McNeil | HB | #8 | 296 | Minnesota Mudders | 12 | $ 47.97 |
| Rookie | Freddie Solomon | WR | #9 | 297 | Dallas Texans (N) | 11 | $ 14.30 |
| Rookie | Haven Moses | WR | #10 | 298 | Dallas Texans (A) | 14 | $ 19.54 |
| Rookie | Donte' Stallworth | WR | #11 | 299 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 5+ | $ 7.52 |
| Rookie | Brad Daluiso | K | #12 | 300 | Misery Riders | 6 | $ 18.91 |
| Rookie | Kris Brown | K | #13 | 301 | Olympia Olympians | 8+ | $ 25.36 |
| Rookie | Todd Peterson | K | #14 | 302 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 11 | $ 31.66 |
| Rookie | Stanley Morgan | WR | #15 | 303 | Washington Salmonbellies | 14 | $ 21.83 |
| Rookie | Plaxico Burress | WR | #16 | 304 | Buffalo Curse | 7+ | $ 12.40 |
| 1967 | Chicago Bears | ST | #17 | 305 | NY/NJ Machine | All | $ 4.87 |
| Rookie | Mark Carrier | WR | #18 | 306 | Miami Finest | 12 | $ 18.69 |
| Rookie | John Brodie | QB | #19 | 307 | Baltimore Dragons | 16 | $ 63.22 |
| Rookie | Alfred Jenkins | WR | #20 | 308 | Pottsville Maroons | 8 | $ 14.20 |
| Rookie | Gary Garrison | WR | #21 | 309 | California Redwoods | 10 | $ 17.04 |
| Rookie | Clem Daniels | HB | #22 | 310 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 8 | $ 35.83 |
| Rookie | Frankie Albert | QB/P | #23 | 311 | Houston K-Cars | 7 | $ 36.91 |
| 1954 | Philadelphia Eagles | D | #24 | 312 | SD Scream'n Daemons | All | $ 33.03 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Jeff Garcia | QB | #1 | 313 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 8 | $ 32.60 |
| Rookie | Jerry Smith | TE | #2 | 314 | Houston K-Cars | 12 | $ 15.24 |
| Rookie | Brent Jones | TE | #3 | 315 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 11 | $ 13.44 |
| Rookie | Boomer Esiason | QB | #4 | 316 | California Redwoods | 14 | $ 57.60 |
| 05-06 | Matt Hasselbeck | QB | #5 | 317 | Pottsville Maroons | 2 | $ 9.15 |
| Rookie | Jerome Barkum | WR/TE | #6 | 318 | Baltimore Dragons | 12 | $ 13.78 |
| Rookie | Alan Ameche | HB | #7 | 319 | Miami Finest | 6 | $ 27.75 |
| Rookie | Steve DeBerg | QB | #8 | 320 | NY/NJ Machine | 17 | $ 53.31 |
| Rookie | Paul Lowe | HB | #9 | 321 | Buffalo Curse | 8 | $ 31.89 |
| 2001 | David Boston | WR | #10 | 322 | Washington Salmonbellies | 1 | $ 2.63 |
| 2002 | Ricky Williams | HB | #11 | 323 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 1 | $ 7.96 |
| Rookie | Bob Trumpy | TE | #12 | 324 | Olympia Olympians | 10 | $ 12.91 |
| Rookie | Chris Chambers | WR | #13 | 325 | Misery Riders | 6+ | $ 11.25 |
| Rookie | Alge Crumpler | TE | #14 | 326 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 6+ | $ 8.83 |
| Rookie | Otis Taylor | WR | #15 | 327 | Dallas Texans (A) | 10 | $ 16.89 |
| Rookie | Louis Lipps | WR | #16 | 328 | Dallas Texans (N) | 8 | $ 12.39 |
| Rookie | Chuck Foreman | HB | #17 | 329 | Minnesota Mudders | 8 | $ 39.09 |
| Rookie | Delvin Williams | HB | #18 | 330 | The Flushing Flash | 7 | $ 31.97 |
| Rookie | Joe Senser | TE | #19 | 331 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 4 | $ 5.54 |
| Rookie | Russ Francis | TE | #20 | 332 | New England Razors | 13 | $ 15.05 |
| Rookie | Eric Metcalf | HB/WR | #21 | 333 | Detroit Icemen | 12 | $ 26.76 |
| Rookie | Darrell Brewster | WR/TE | #22 | 334 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 8 | $ 10.63 |
| Rookie | Mark Clayton (Mia) | WR | #23 | 335 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 11 | $ 18.16 |
| Rookie | Lynn Swann | WR | #24 | 336 | Oakland Outlaws | 9 | $ 13.37 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | John Stallworth | WR | #1 | 337 | Oakland Outlaws | 13 | $ 19.04 |
| 1957 | Washington Redskins | ST | #2 | 338 | Juneau Sucker Holes | All | $ 4.92 |
| Rookie | Lawrence McCutcheon | HB | #3 | 339 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 9 | $ 38.30 |
| Rookie | Jake Reed | WR | #4 | 340 | Detroit Icemen | 11 | $ 14.49 |
| Rookie | Jamal Anderson | HB | #5 | 341 | New England Razors | 5 | $ 24.13 |
| 1952 | Bud Grant | TE | #6 | 342 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 1 | $ 2.23 |
| 2000 | Tennessee Titans | ST | #7 | 343 | The Flushing Flash | All | $ 5.03 |
| Rookie | Eddie Brown | WR | #8 | 344 | Minnesota Mudders | 7 | $ 12.27 |
| Rookie | Steven Jackson | HB | #9 | 345 | Dallas Texans (N) | 3+ | $ 16.05 |
| Rookie | Jimmie Giles | TE | #10 | 346 | Dallas Texans (A) | 13 | $ 13.05 |
| Rookie | Reggie Roby | P | #11 | 347 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 16 | $ 24.22 |
| Rookie | Mark Royals | P | #12 | 348 | Misery Riders | 14 | $ 18.95 |
| Rookie | Darrell Jackson | WR | #13 | 349 | Olympia Olympians | 7+ | $ 12.58 |
| Rookie | Mike Quick | WR | #14 | 350 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 9 | $ 12.62 |
| 05-06 | Andre Johnson | WR | #15 | 351 | Washington Salmonbellies | 2 | $ 4.00 |
| Rookie | Wesley Walls | TE | #16 | 352 | Buffalo Curse | 13 | $ 14.12 |
| Rookie | Jason Witten | TE | #17 | 353 | NY/NJ Machine | 4+ | $ 6.84 |
| Rookie | Matt Snell | HB | #18 | 354 | Miami Finest | 6 | $ 27.32 |
| Rookie | Fred Biletnikoff | WR | #19 | 355 | Baltimore Dragons | 14 | $ 23.08 |
| 2002 | New York Jets | ST | #20 | 356 | Pottsville Maroons | All | $ 5.02 |
| Rookie | Jim Mitchell | TE | #21 | 357 | California Redwoods | 11 | $ 12.94 |
| Rookie | Horace Gillom | TE/P | #22 | 358 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 10 | $ 18.38 |
| Rookie | Earl Morrall | QB/P | #23 | 359 | Houston K-Cars | 21 | $ 37.93 |
| 05-06 | Donald Driver | WR | #24 | 360 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 2 | $ 4.70 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Bart Starr | QB | #1 | 361 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 16 | $ 50.26 |
| 1951 | Fran Polsfoot | TE | #2 | 362 | Houston K-Cars | 1 | $ 2.14 |
| Rookie | Johnny Lujack | QB/K | #3 | 363 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 4 | $ 20.25 |
| Rookie | Deuce McAllister | HB | #4 | 364 | California Redwoods | 6+ | $ 26.17 |
| Rookie | Ted Kwalick | TE | #5 | 365 | Pottsville Maroons | 7 | $ 7.39 |
| Rookie | Larry Brown | HB | #6 | 366 | Baltimore Dragons | 8 | $ 37.44 |
| Rookie | Glenn Dobbs | QB/P | #7 | 367 | Miami Finest | 4 | $ 21.91 |
| Rookie | Al Del Greco | K | #8 | 368 | NY/NJ Machine | 17 | $ 48.07 |
| Rookie | Joe Horn | WR | #9 | 369 | Buffalo Curse | 11 | $ 16.83 |
| 2003 | Kansas City Chiefs | ST | #10 | 370 | Washington Salmonbellies | All | $ 4.97 |
| Rookie | Anthony Carter | WR | #11 | 371 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 10 | $ 16.10 |
| 1967 | Cleveland Browns | ST | #12 | 372 | Olympia Olympians | All | $ 4.94 |
| Rookie | Charlie Conerly | QB/P | #13 | 373 | Misery Riders | 14 | $ 48.60 |
| Rookie | Roy Green | WR | #14 | 374 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 13 | $ 19.33 |
| Rookie | Buddy Dial | WR | #15 | 375 | Dallas Texans (A) | 8 | $ 11.20 |
| 1983 | Miami Dolphins | ST | #16 | 376 | Dallas Texans (N) | All | $ 4.83 |
| Rookie | Ken Dilger | TE | #17 | 377 | Minnesota Mudders | 10 | $ 11.81 |
| Rookie | Rohn Stark | P | #18 | 378 | The Flushing Flash | 16 | $ 23.85 |
| 05-06 | Laveranues Coles | WR | #19 | 379 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 2 | $ 4.18 |
| Rookie | Keenan McCardell | WR | #20 | 380 | New England Razors | 14+ | $ 23.52 |
| Rookie | Ahmad Rashad | WR | #21 | 381 | Detroit Icemen | 10 | $ 17.84 |
| 2006 | Roy Williams | WR | #22 | 382 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 1 | $ 2.35 |
| Rookie | Warren Wells | WR | #23 | 383 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 1 | $ 2.25 |
| Rookie | Jim Zorn | QB | #24 | 384 | Oakland Outlaws | 10 | $ 35.29 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Joe Cribbs | HB | #1 | 385 | Oakland Outlaws | 8 | $ 32.46 |
| Rookie | Freddie Jones | TE | #2 | 386 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 8 | $ 11.76 |
| Rookie | Phil Dawson | K | #3 | 387 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 8+ | $ 23.69 |
| 1971 | Miami Dolphins | ST | #4 | 388 | Detroit Icemen | All | $ 4.88 |
| Rookie | Warrick Dunn | HB | #5 | 389 | New England Razors | 10+ | $ 48.54 |
| Rookie | Dave Krieg | QB | #6 | 390 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 16 | $ 57.06 |
| Rookie | Homer Jones | WR | #7 | 391 | The Flushing Flash | 6 | $ 9.96 |
| Rookie | Flipper Anderson | WR | #8 | 392 | Minnesota Mudders | 7 | $ 10.50 |
| Rookie | Ricky Bell | HB | #9 | 393 | Dallas Texans (N) | 5 | $ 16.94 |
| Rookie | Troy Aikman | QB | #10 | 394 | Dallas Texans (A) | 12 | $ 54.16 |
| Rookie | Phil Simms | QB | #11 | 395 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 13 | $ 52.52 |
| Rookie | J.T. Smith | WR | #12 | 396 | Misery Riders | 12 | $ 16.42 |
| Rookie | Terry Allen | HB | #13 | 397 | Olympia Olympians | 10 | $ 40.77 |
| Rookie | Walter White | TE | #14 | 398 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 5 | $ 6.72 |
| Rookie | Pete Retzlaff | TE/WR | #15 | 399 | Washington Salmonbellies | 11 | $ 17.30 |
| Rookie | Sean Landeta | P | #16 | 400 | Buffalo Curse | 20 | $ 30.42 |
| Rookie | Terry Glenn | WR | #17 | 401 | NY/NJ Machine | 11+ | $ 17.52 |
| Rookie | Archie Manning | QB | #18 | 402 | Miami Finest | 12 | $ 42.90 |
| Rookie | John Hadl | QB/P | #19 | 403 | Baltimore Dragons | 16 | $ 63.41 |
| Rookie | Jack Russell | TE | #20 | 404 | Pottsville Maroons | 4 | $ 3.54 |
| Rookie | Milt Morin | TE | #21 | 405 | California Redwoods | 10 | $ 12.02 |
| Rookie | Danny Abramowicz | WR | #22 | 406 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 8 | $ 14.21 |
| Rookie | Maurice Jones-Drew | HB | #23 | 407 | Houston K-Cars | 1+ | $ 5.35 |
| Rookie | Riley Odoms | TE | #24 | 408 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 11 | $ 15.55 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Marv Hubbard | HB | #1 | 409 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 8 | $ 27.81 |
| Rookie | Marcus Robinson | WR | #2 | 410 | Houston K-Cars | 8+ | $ 10.10 |
| Rookie | George McAfee | HB/P | #3 | 411 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 7 | $ 16.68 |
| Rookie | Calvin Hill | HB | #4 | 412 | California Redwoods | 10 | $ 39.35 |
| Rookie | Travis Henry | HB | #5 | 413 | Pottsville Maroons | 6+ | $ 23.94 |
| Rookie | Steve Jordan | TE | #6 | 414 | Baltimore Dragons | 13 | $ 16.21 |
| Rookie | Chris Cooley | TE | #7 | 415 | Miami Finest | 3+ | $ 4.72 |
| Rookie | John David Crow | HB | #8 | 416 | NY/NJ Machine | 9 | $ 38.75 |
| 04-06 | Javon Walker | WR | #9 | 417 | Buffalo Curse | 2 | $ 4.54 |
| Rookie | Marv Cook | TE | #10 | 418 | Washington Salmonbellies | 7 | $ 7.24 |
| Rookie | Gerald Riggs | HB | #11 | 419 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 10 | $ 41.08 |
| Rookie | Aaron Brooks | QB | #12 | 420 | Olympia Olympians | 7+ | $ 30.44 |
| Rookie | John Brockington | HB | #13 | 421 | Misery Riders | 7 | $ 30.77 |
| Rookie | Chuck Muncie | HB | #14 | 422 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 9 | $ 41.33 |
| Rookie | Charlie Garner | HB | #15 | 423 | Dallas Texans (A) | 10 | $ 40.42 |
| Rookie | Brian Westbrook | HB | #16 | 424 | Dallas Texans (N) | 5+ | $ 20.39 |
| Rookie | Bill Anderson | WR/TE | #17 | 425 | Minnesota Mudders | 8 | $ 8.15 |
| Rookie | Eric Green | TE | #18 | 426 | The Flushing Flash | 10 | $ 11.33 |
| Rookie | Santonio Holmes | WR | #19 | 427 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 1+ | $ 1.75 |
| Rookie | Terry Bradshaw | QB | #20 | 428 | New England Razors | 13 | $ 50.05 |
| Rookie | Eddie Murray | K | #21 | 429 | Detroit Icemen | 17 | $ 47.51 |
| 1994 | Cleveland Browns | ST | #22 | 430 | Cleveland MoonDogs | All | $ 4.68 |
| Rookie | Kay Eakin | P/QB | #23 | 431 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 2 | $ 3.98 |
| Rookie | Billy Joe DuPree | TE | #24 | 432 | Oakland Outlaws | 11 | $ 10.82 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Jack Snow | WR | #1 | 433 | Oakland Outlaws | 11 | $ 15.10 |
| Rookie | Cookie Gilchrist | HB/K | #2 | 434 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 5 | $ 25.69 |
| Rookie | Ray Poole | TE/K | #3 | 435 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 6 | $ 8.30 |
| Rookie | Yale Lary | P | #4 | 436 | Detroit Icemen | 11 | $ 17.01 |
| Rookie | Marques Colston | WR | #5 | 437 | New England Razors | 1+ | $ 1.96 |
| Rookie | Heath Miller | TE | #6 | 438 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 2+ | $ 2.43 |
| Rookie | Steve Van Buren | HB | #7 | 439 | The Flushing Flash | 8 | $ 38.94 |
| Rookie | Wilbert Montgomery | HB | #8 | 440 | Minnesota Mudders | 9 | $ 39.67 |
| Rookie | Byron Leftwich | QB | #9 | 441 | Dallas Texans (N) | 4+ | $ 13.44 |
| Rookie | Henry Childs | TE | #10 | 442 | Dallas Texans (A) | 7 | $ 8.45 |
| Rookie | Johnny Mitchell | TE | #11 | 443 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 5 | $ 5.33 |
| Rookie | Desmond Clark | TE | #12 | 444 | Misery Riders | 8+ | $ 7.57 |
| Rookie | Mike Anderson | HB | #13 | 445 | Olympia Olympians | 6+ | $ 18.81 |
| Rookie | Dean McAdams | P/K/QB | #14 | 446 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 3 | $ 7.09 |
| Rookie | Norm Johnson | K | #15 | 447 | Washington Salmonbellies | 18 | $ 52.70 |
| 1978 | Washington Redskins | ST | #16 | 448 | Buffalo Curse | All | $ 4.63 |
| 1995 | Robert Brooks | WR | #17 | 449 | NY/NJ Machine | 1 | $ 2.56 |
| Rookie | Jim Whelan | TE | #18 | 450 | Miami Finest | 6 | $ 7.95 |
| Rookie | Ron Kramer | TE | #19 | 451 | Baltimore Dragons | 10 | $ 10.06 |
| Rookie | Ken Kavanaugh | WR | #20 | 452 | Pottsville Maroons | 7 | $ 9.40 |
| Rookie | Stephen Davis | HB | #21 | 453 | California Redwoods | 10+ | $ 36.05 |
| Rookie | Brian Griese | QB | #22 | 454 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 8+ | $ 25.44 |
| Rookie | Bill Brooks | WR | #23 | 455 | Houston K-Cars | 11 | $ 18.00 |
| 1946 | Bill Dewell | TE | #24 | 456 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 1 | $ 1.81 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Willie Gault | WR | #1 | 457 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 11 | $ 13.64 |
| Rookie | Tank Younger | HB | #2 | 458 | Houston K-Cars | 10 | $ 30.43 |
| Rookie | Leon Hart | TE/HB | #3 | 459 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 8 | $ 12.88 |
| Rookie | Don Meredith | QB | #4 | 460 | California Redwoods | 9 | $ 32.10 |
| Rookie | Dante Lavelli | WR | #5 | 461 | Pottsville Maroons | 11 | $ 17.13 |
| Rookie | Norm Snead | QB | #6 | 462 | Baltimore Dragons | 15 | $ 56.11 |
| Rookie | Jake Delhomme | QB | #7 | 463 | Miami Finest | 4+ | $ 20.20 |
| Rookie | Garrison Hearst | HB | #8 | 464 | NY/NJ Machine | 10 | $ 39.01 |
| 1959 | Bob Schnelker | TE | #9 | 465 | Buffalo Curse | 1 | $ 1.77 |
| Rookie | Keith Byars | HB | #10 | 466 | Washington Salmonbellies | 11 | $ 31.14 |
| Rookie | Jim Everett | QB | #11 | 467 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 12 | $ 53.09 |
| Rookie | Mark Rypien | QB | #12 | 468 | Olympia Olympians | 10 | $ 26.79 |
| Rookie | Eric Johnson | TE | #13 | 469 | Misery Riders | 4+ | $ 5.26 |
| Rookie | John Henry Johnson | HB | #14 | 470 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 12 | $ 46.53 |
| Rookie | Keith Lincoln | HB/K | #15 | 471 | Dallas Texans (A) | 8 | $ 27.45 |
| Rookie | Jermaine Wiggins | TE | #16 | 472 | Dallas Texans (N) | 7+ | $ 6.43 |
| Rookie | Bert Jones | QB | #17 | 473 | Minnesota Mudders | 9 | $ 34.51 |
| Rookie | Chet Mutryn | HB | #18 | 474 | The Flushing Flash | 5 | $ 24.31 |
| Rookie | Barry Foster | HB | #19 | 475 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 5 | $ 18.90 |
| Rookie | Tom Tupa | QB/P | #20 | 476 | New England Razors | 13 | $ 19.64 |
| Rookie | "Special Delivery" Jones | HB | #21 | 477 | Detroit Icemen | 4 | $ 11.67 |
| Rookie | Ernie Green | HB | #22 | 478 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 7 | $ 26.56 |
| Rookie | David Carr | QB | #23 | 479 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 5+ | $ 18.51 |
| Rookie | Tom Rathman | HB | #24 | 480 | Oakland Outlaws | 9 | $ 20.83 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Mike Hollis | K | #1 | 481 | Oakland Outlaws | 8 | $ 22.37 |
| Rookie | Michael Bennett | HB | #2 | 482 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 6+ | $ 18.24 |
| Rookie | Mike Pruitt | HB | #3 | 483 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 11 | $ 41.94 |
| 2006 | Braylon Edwards | WR | #4 | 484 | Detroit Icemen | 1 | $ 1.87 |
| Rookie | Bubba Franks | TE | #5 | 485 | New England Razors | 7+ | $ 7.21 |
| Rookie | Carl Pickens | WR | #6 | 486 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 9 | $ 14.97 |
| Rookie | Joe Ferguson | QB | #7 | 487 | The Flushing Flash | 15 | $ 46.67 |
| Rookie | Sam Cunningham | HB | #8 | 488 | Minnesota Mudders | 9 | $ 34.37 |
| Rookie | Ike Hilliard | WR | #9 | 489 | Dallas Texans (N) | 9+ | $ 12.73 |
| Rookie | Dickie Post | HB | #10 | 490 | Dallas Texans (A) | 5 | $ 18.02 |
| Rookie | John Taylor | WR | #11 | 491 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 9 | $ 11.85 |
| Rookie | Vince Young | QB | #12 | 492 | Misery Riders | 1+ | $ 2.86 |
| Rookie | Charlie Brown (Wsh) | WR | #13 | 493 | Olympia Olympians | 6 | $ 8.17 |
| Rookie | Willis McGahee | HB | #14 | 494 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 3+ | $ 13.89 |
| Rookie | Earnest Byner | HB | #15 | 495 | Washington Salmonbellies | 14 | $ 52.17 |
| Rookie | Chris Warren | HB | #16 | 496 | Buffalo Curse | 11 | $ 39.96 |
| Rookie | Jim Mutscheller | TE/WR | #17 | 497 | NY/NJ Machine | 8 | $ 10.58 |
| Rookie | Marlin Briscoe | QB/WR | #18 | 498 | Miami Finest | 9 | $ 12.75 |
| Rookie | Dick Bass | HB | #19 | 499 | Baltimore Dragons | 9 | $ 37.33 |
| Rookie | Mark Van Eeghan | HB | #20 | 500 | Pottsville Maroons | 9 | $ 37.50 |
| Rookie | Sammy White | WR | #21 | 501 | California Redwoods | 10 | $ 15.12 |
| Rookie | Joe Maniaci | K/HB | #22 | 502 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 1 | $ 5.19 |
| Rookie | Leon Clarke | TE/WR | #23 | 503 | Houston K-Cars | 7 | $ 6.61 |
| Rookie | Mel Gray (St.L) | WR | #24 | 504 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 12 | $ 15.67 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Lyvonia "Stump" Mitchell | HB | #1 | 505 | SD Scream'n Daemons | 8 | $ 30.19 |
| Rookie | Greg Cook | QB | #2 | 506 | Houston K-Cars | 1 | $ 3.35 |
| 1952 | Pittsburgh Steelers | ST | #3 | 507 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | All | $ 4.77 |
| Rookie | Don Norton | WR | #4 | 508 | California Redwoods | 7 | $ 8.84 |
| Rookie | Jim Hart | QB | #5 | 509 | Pottsville Maroons | 17 | $ 62.79 |
| Rookie | Don Chandler | HB/P/K | #6 | 510 | Baltimore Dragons | 12 | $ 23.99 |
| Rookie | Lee Evans | WR | #7 | 511 | Miami Finest | 3+ | $ 5.78 |
| Rookie | Derrick Mason | WR | #8 | 512 | NY/NJ Machine | 10+ | $ 16.52 |
| Rookie | Pete Mitchell | TE | #9 | 513 | Buffalo Curse | 8 | $ 8.71 |
| Rookie | Larry Centers | HB | #10 | 514 | Washington Salmonbellies | 13 | $ 32.18 |
| Rookie | Frank Sanders | WR | #11 | 515 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 9 | $ 15.00 |
| Rookie | Jeff Burkett | P/WR | #12 | 516 | Olympia Olympians | 1 | $ 2.39 |
| Rookie | Bob Boyd | WR | #13 | 517 | Misery Riders | 7 | $ 9.20 |
| Rookie | Roger Carr | WR | #14 | 518 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 10 | $ 11.89 |
| Rookie | Duane Thomas | HB | #15 | 519 | Dallas Texans (A) | 4 | $ 12.92 |
| Rookie | Lamont Jordan | HB | #16 | 520 | Dallas Texans (N) | 6+ | $ 14.75 |
| Rookie | David Hill | TE | #17 | 521 | Minnesota Mudders | 12 | $ 13.19 |
| Rookie | Marcus Pollard | TE | #18 | 522 | The Flushing Flash | 11+ | $ 10.88 |
| Rookie | Dick Hoak | HB | #19 | 523 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 10 | $ 28.40 |
| Rookie | Mark Chmura | TE | #20 | 524 | New England Razors | 6 | $ 6.17 |
| Rookie | James Jett | WR | #21 | 525 | Detroit Icemen | 9 | $ 10.08 |
| Rookie | Dave Logan | WR | #22 | 526 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 9 | $ 10.95 |
| Rookie | Anthony Miller | WR | #23 | 527 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 10 | $ 18.72 |
| Rookie | Clint Didier | TE | #24 | 528 | Oakland Outlaws | 8 | $ 5.52 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Bryan Barker | P | #1 | 529 | Oakland Outlaws | 16 | $ 21.41 |
| Rookie | George Sauer | WR | #2 | 530 | Juneau Sucker Holes | 6 | $ 11.39 |
| 81-82 | Ricky Feacher | WR | #3 | 531 | Cleveland MoonDogs | 2 | $ 2.91 |
| Rookie | Darryl Lamonica | QB/P | #4 | 532 | Detroit Icemen | 12 | $ 35.34 |
| Rookie | Drew Hill | WR | #5 | 533 | New England Razors | 14 | $ 20.23 |
| Rookie | Antwaan Randle El | WR | #6 | 534 | Pittsburgh Yinsers | 5+ | $ 6.53 |
| Rookie | Ken Stabler | QB | #7 | 535 | The Flushing Flash | 13 | $ 46.59 |
| Rookie | Doug Cosbie | TE | #8 | 536 | Minnesota Mudders | 10 | $ 10.73 |
| Rookie | Koy Detmer | QB | #9 | 537 | Dallas Texans (N) | 6 | $ 2.98 |
| Rookie | Johnny Strzykalski | HB | #10 | 538 | Dallas Texans (A) | 7 | $ 26.21 |
| Rookie | Michael Haynes | WR | #11 | 539 | Golden Gate Gibbs | 10 | $ 14.29 |
| Rookie | Rueben Mayes | HB | #12 | 540 | Misery Riders | 5 | $ 17.20 |
| Rookie | Willard Dewveal | TE | #13 | 541 | Olympia Olympians | 6 | $ 8.30 |
| Rookie | Jon Kitna | QB | #14 | 542 | Cincinnati Bungholes | 8+ | $ 32.74 |
| Rookie | Todd Sauerbrun | P | #15 | 543 | Washington Salmonbellies | 10 | $ 15.56 |
| Rookie | Steve McNair | QB | #16 | 544 | Buffalo Curse | 12+ | $ 51.91 |
| Rookie | Rickey Dudley | TE | #17 | 545 | NY/NJ Machine | 8 | $ 7.76 |
| Rookie | Jim Keane | WR | #18 | 546 | Miami Finest | 7 | $ 9.73 |
| Rookie | Tommy McDonald | HB/WR | #19 | 547 | Baltimore Dragons | 12 | $ 19.73 |
| Rookie | Fred Arbanas | TE | #20 | 548 | Pottsville Maroons | 9 | $ 8.37 |
| Rookie | Billy Cannon | HB/TE | #21 | 549 | California Redwoods | 11 | $ 23.57 |
| 1995 | San Francisco 49ers | D | #22 | 550 | Jacksonville Skynyrds | All | $ 33.90 |
| Rookie | Larry Barnes | HB/P/K | #23 | 551 | Houston K-Cars | 2 | $ 3.16 |
| 1962 | Washington Redskins | ST | #24 | 552 | SD Scream'n Daemons | All | $ 4.85 |
| YEAR | PLAYER/UNIT | POS | PCK | OVR | TEAM | YRS | SALARY |
| Rookie | Chris Gardocki | P | New England Razors | 15+ | $ 21.43 | ||
| 84-85 | Lynn Dickey | QB | California Redwoods | 2 | $ 7.89 | ||
| Rookie | Rian Lindell | K | SD Scream'n Daemons | 7+ | $ 20.90 | ||
| Rookie | Rick Tuten | P | SD Scream'n Daemons | 10 | $ 15.01 | ||
| 1966 | Kansas City Chiefs | OL | SD Scream'n Daemons | All | $ 5.20 | ||
| Rookie | Willie Frazier | TE | Houston K-Cars | 10 | $ 8.86 | ||
| Rookie | Rich Caster | WR/TE | Houston K-Cars | 12 | $ 14.05 | ||
| Rookie | Jeff George | QB | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 10 | $ 41.82 | ||
| Rookie | Neil Rackers | K | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 7+ | $ 19.75 | ||
| Rookie | Dick Gordon | WR | Jacksonville Skynyrds | 10 | $ 10.46 | ||
| Rookie | Bobby Joe Green | P | Cincinnati Bungholes | 13 | $ 18.54 | ||
| Rookie | Darnay Scott | WR | Cincinnati Bungholes | 8 | $ 13.24 | ||
| Rookie | Bob Mann | WR | Cincinnati Bungholes | 6 | $ 8.88 | ||
| Rookie | Pat Brady | P/QB | Olympia Olympians | 3 | $ 5.99 | ||
| Rookie | Isaac Curtis | WR | Olympia Olympians | 12 | $ 17.68 | ||
| Rookie | Kevin Johnson | WR | Olympia Olympians | 7 | $ 10.80 |