| SEASON | TEAM NAME | OWNER | OVERALL | REGULAR | HOME | AWAY | CONF | DIV | POST | FINISHED |
| 1951-52/1981-82 | St. Louis Mighty Prophets | tarheel1991 | 74-19 | 67-15 | 35-6 | 32-9 | 46-12 | 36-4 | 7-4 | 1st MW - Lost Conf. Final (LA) |
| 1952-53/1982-83 | St. Louis Mighty Prophets | tarheel1991 | 71-30 | 59-23 | 33-8 | 26-15 | 42-16 | 32-8 | 12-7 | 1st MW - Won Championship |
| 1953-54/1983-84 | St. Louis Mighty Prophets | tarheel1991 | 69-27 | 57-25 | 29-12 | 28-13 | 41-17 | 27-13 | 12-2 | 1st MW - Won Championship |
| 1954-55/1984-85 | St. Louis Mighty Prophets | tarheel1991 | 66-34 | 56-26 | 30-11 | 26-15 | 43-15 | 32-8 | 10-8 | 1st MW - Lost Finals (Phil) |
| 1955-56/1985-86 | St. Louis Mighty Prophets | tarheel1991 | 52-43 | 46-36 | 29-12 | 17-24 | 35-23 | 24-16 | 6-7 | 2nd MW - Lost 2nd Round (Por) |
| 1956-57/1986-87 | St. Louis Mighty Prophets | tarheel1991 | 7-75 | 7-75 | 6-35 | 1-40 | 5-53 | 3-37 | 0-0 | 6th MW - Missed Playoffs |
| 1957-58/1987-88 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 12-70 | 12-70 | 7-34 | 5-36 | 8-50 | 7-33 | 0-0 | 6th MW - Missed Playoffs |
| 1958-59/1988-89 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 13-69 | 13-69 | 7-34 | 6-35 | 11-47 | 8-32 | 0-0 | 6th MW - Missed Playoffs |
| 1959-60/1989-90 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 14-68 | 14-68 | 9-32 | 5-36 | 6-52 | 4-36 | 0-0 | 6th MW - Missed Playoffs |
| 1960-61/1990-91 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 38-44 | 38-44 | 22-19 | 16-25 | 25-33 | 16-24 | 0-0 | 5th MW - Missed Playoffs |
| 1961-62/1991-92 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 66-23 | 63-19 | 33-8 | 30-11 | 46-12 | 31-9 | 3-4 | 1st MW - Lost 1st Round (Hou) |
| 1962-63/1992-93 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 53-35 | 51-31 | 29-12 | 22-19 | 38-20 | 28-12 | 2-4 | 2nd MW - Lost 1st Round (Por) |
| 1963-64/1993-94 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 82-15 | 70-12 | 35-6 | 35-6 | 51-7 | 36-4 | 12-3 | 1st MW - Won Championship |
| 1964-65/1994-95 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 80-15 | 68-14 | 36-5 | 32-9 | 45-13 | 32-8 | 12-1 | 1st MW - Won Championship |
| 1965-66/1995-96 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 71-20 | 67-15 | 34-7 | 33-8 | 48-10 | 37-3 | 4-5 | 1st MW - Lost Conf. Final (Arz) |
| 1966-67/1996-97 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 84-10 | 72-10 | 37-4 | 35-6 | 54-4 | 36-4 | 12-0 | 1st MW - Won Championship |
| 1967-68/1997-98 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 61-27 | 59-23 | 30-11 | 29-12 | 46-12 | 31-9 | 2-4 | 1st MW - Lost 2nd Round (Mil) |
| 1968-69/1998-99 | St. Louis Wormz | tarheel1991 | 71-29 | 59-23 | 32-9 | 27-14 | 44-14 | 30-10 | 12-6 | 1st MW - Won Championship |
| 1969-70/1999-00 | St. Louis Glovez | tarheel1991 | 69-25 | 62-20 | 33-8 | 29-12 | 46-12 | 33-7 | 7-5 | 1st MW - Lost Conf. Final (Hou) |
| 1970-71/2000-01 | St. Louis Glovez | tarheel1991 | 55-33 | 53-29 | 30-11 | 23-18 | 37-21 | 27-13 | 2-4 | 2nd MW - Lost 1st Round (LA) |
| 1971-72/2001-02 | St. Louis Zeros | tarheel1991 | 56-30 | 56-26 | 33-8 | 23-18 | 42-16 | 31-9 | 0-4 | 1st MW - Lost 2nd Round (Oak) |
| 1972-73/2002-03 | St. Louis Zeros | tarheel1991 | 61-32 | 57-25 | 29-12 | 28-13 | 41-17 | 31-9 | 4-7 | 1st MW - Lost Conf. Final (Port) |
| 1973-74/2003-04 | St. Louis Zeros | tarheel1991 | 49-38 | 48-34 | 25-16 | 23-18 | 35-23 | 25-15 | 1-4 | 3rd MW - Lost 1st Round (Oak) |
| 1974-75/2004-05 | St. Louis Zeros | tarheel1991 | 71-27 | 61-21 | 32-9 | 29-12 | 46-12 | 33-7 | 10-6 | 1st MW - Lost Finals (Phil) |
| 1975-76/2005-06 | St. Louis Zeros | tarheel1991 | 39-43 | 39-43 | 25-16 | 14-27 | 23-35 | 14-26 | 0-0 | 4th MW - Missed Playoffs |
| 1976-77/2006-07 | St. Louis Zeros | tarheel1991 | 45-37 | 45-37 | 29-12 | 16-25 | 32-26 | 23-17 | 0-0 | 4th MW - Missed Playoffs |
| 1977-78/2007-08 | St. Louis Spaniards | tarheel1991 | 47-42 | 44-38 | 24-17 | 20-21 | 33-25 | 24-16 | 3-4 | 3rd MW - Lost 1st Round (LA) |
| 1978-79/2008-09 | St. Louis Spaniards | tarheel1991 | 57-31 | 55-27 | 27-14 | 28-13 | 39-19 | 26-14 | 2-4 | 1st MW - Lost 2nd Round (LA) |
| 1979-80/2009-10 | St. Louis Spaniards | tarheel1991 | 38-44 | 38-44 | 23-18 | 15-26 | 29-29 | 20-20 | 0-0 | 4th MW - Missed Playoffs |
| 1980-81/2010-11 | St. Louis Spaniards | tarheel1991 | 54-43 | 46-36 | 25-16 | 21-20 | 32-26 | 22-18 | 8-7 | 2nd MW - Lost Conf. Final (Por) |
| St. Louis Spaniards | TOTALS | 1625-1078 | 1482-978 | 808-422 | 674-556 | 1069-671 | 759-441 | 143-100 | ||
| SEASON | TEAM NAME | OWNER | OVERALL | REGULAR | HOME | AWAY | CONF | DIV | POST | FINISHED |